Palmyra Area Church Softball Champions
| 1993 - First EC |
|---|
| 1994 - Palm Lutheran |
| 1995 - Palm Lutheran |
| 1996 - First EC |
| 1997 - Palm Lutheran |
| 1998 - Campbelltowm UM |
| 1999 - Lawn EC |
| 2000 - Palm Lutheran |
| 2001 - Campbelltowm UM |
| 2002 - Campbelltowm UM |
| 2003 - United Zion |
| 2004 - Hershey Free |
| 2005 - United Zion and First UM |
| 2006 - United Zion |
| 2007 - Annville Church of the Brethren |
| 2008 - Annville Church of the Brethren |
| 2009 - Annville Church of the Brethren |
| 2010 - Annville Church of the Brethren |